Blog · November 20, 2026
Our first live test: in Columbus, the top 1% sold at nearly 7 times the average
On September 22 we gave every home in Franklin County, Ohio, home to Columbus, a Motsele Score. Then we waited to see which homes actually sold. The top 1% sold at 6.7 times the rate of all homes. Before launch, our test on past sales said to expect 5.5 times.
That is good news. It is also one market and about seven weeks of sales. Here is what we did, what we found, and what it does not prove.
What the Motsele Score is
The Motsele Score ranks each home against the other homes in its county. It adds up signs in public records that, in the past, came before a sale. In Franklin County there are fifteen. A few of them:
- The owner’s tax bill goes to a different address than the home.
- The county charged the owner for mowing, boarding up or other upkeep.
- Taxes are $2,000 or more overdue, or there is a late penalty on the bill.
- The home was bought in the last two years, or a company or trust owns it.
Some signs push the score down. A home owned for more than 20 years, or a registered rental, scores lower, because those homes sold less often.
The score is not a percent chance. It does not say what any owner plans to do. It says this home looks like the homes that sold before.
How we tested it
Think of it like sealing a list of guesses in an envelope before the game, then opening it after.
- Seal the list. We scored 310,408 one- to three-family homes from county records dated before launch. Nothing after September 22 was allowed in.
- Check the seal. To be sure we were grading the launch scores and not a later version, we rebuilt them from the county files we saved in September, with the computer’s calendar set back to September 22. The rebuild matched launch exactly: 119,406 homes met our bar for a page, the same count as on launch day.
- Wait for real sales. The Franklin County Auditor records every sale. From September 22 to November 13, 1,782 of those homes sold in a sale the Auditor marks as valid, with a price.
- Open the envelope. We compared how often the top-scored homes sold with how often all homes sold.
What we found
- All homes: about 6 in every 1,000 sold (0.57%).
- Top 1% by Motsele Score (3,104 homes): 119 sold, about 38 in every 1,000 (3.83%). That is 6.7 times the rate of all homes.
- Top 10%: 2.1 times the rate of all homes.
- Our test before launch, on homes the model never saw, put the top 1% at 5.5 times.
The order held too. We split homes into groups from highest score to lowest, and each group sold at least as often as the group below it.
What this does not prove
- It is one market. Columbus only. We ran the same check on Cincinnati (Hamilton County) the same day. That result is not clear yet. We will run it again in December, when more sales are in.
- It is about seven weeks of sales. That is short. A slow or busy few weeks could move the number.
- The number has a range. With 119 sales in the top group, the true figure is likely somewhere between 5.6 and 7.9 times. The low end is right at our 5.5 times estimate. So we can say the top homes sold far more often than average. We cannot yet say for sure they beat our estimate.
- It is about groups, not one home. Even in the top 1%, about 96 in 100 homes did not sell in these weeks. A high score is not a promise that any one owner will sell.
- What counts as a sale matters. We counted sales the Auditor marks as valid. If we count every sale with a price, the top 1% sold at 6.4 times.
What’s next
We will keep checking scores against real sales, in more markets and over longer stretches. We will post what we find here, whether it holds up or not.
Scores are built from Franklin County Auditor records. Sales: Auditor transfer records, September 22 to November 13, 2026. Questions or corrections: support@motsele.com.